Extracts from the reviews (Cottesloe Theatre,
with first cast)
""Thank God life ends. We'd never survive it!" Thus the doctor
in Patrick Marber's wonderful new comedy of sex and modern manners. Marber,
who writes for and with Steve Coogan on TV, made an accomplished playwriting
debut with his poker play Dealer's Choice at the National two years ago.
Closer has only four characters but is infinitely more striking, a sort
of Private Lives for the late 1990s, with brutal language to match and
an ingenious narrative scheme which duplicates the relationships into
the musical form of a quadrille. The doctor Larry (Ciaran Hinds) tends
Alice (Liza Walker), a waif-like stripper and free spirit, who has grazed
her leg in a road accident. She has been plucked from the kerb by a journalist,
Dan (Clive Owen), who works in obituaries. The fourth participant is
the photographer Anna (Sally Dexter) who exhibits a portrait of Alice
after photographing Dan for his new book jacket. Dan fancies Anna, having
started to live with Alice, who in turn intrigues Larry. In one brilliantly
hilarious scene, which establishes the Internet as an unexpected agent
of new drama, Dan and Larry communicate in a web-site dialogue projected
on the back wall. The action, covering about four years, is fluidly arranged
within a governing visual metaphor of mortality, the glazed Doulton tablets
in the London public gardens known as Postman's Park. There, Alice has
found her identity. There, Dan once shared an egg sandwich with his dad.
There, forgotten people are remembered. But not dying means living, and
loving. The French call each orgasm un petit mort. Marber's characters
set about raising this common condition to a malingering disease. The
play reeks of hilarious discussion about sex, jealous cross-questioning
and accusations. ('You're old enough to be her ancestor!' cries a disgusted
Anna after a new infidelity hits the bedstead.) The two men glide in
and out of the same scene as Anna deals with them in differing time planes,
deciding to sleep with Larry for old time's sake while Dan compels her
to tell the truth about his potency. Marber directs his own blisteringly
well-written play, in this case a good idea as it has emerged slowly
from the National's invaluable studio facility. Every life matters a
lot is the ultimate message of a comedy that seems ironically to celebrate
the wonders of physical indulgence and satiety. This is the best acted
play in London, the sexiest and the most profoundly uplifting. A palpable
hit." The Daily Mail
****************************************
"
Of the many four-letter obscenities in Patrick Marber's thrilling
London love story for the Nineties, "love"' is undoubtedly
the most brutal. Caustically funny and very moving, this intimate four-hander
fulfils the promise of Marber's. debut play, Dealer's Choice. Closer
concerns four people who come together, come apart, swap partners,
hate and hurt each other. It sounds trite and, in some ways, it is.
The language of love is the oldest, most devalued dramatic currency
in the book. But Marber's play, which he also impressively directs,
has a depth and a ruthless contemporary edge that makes you look at
even the most cliched expression of affection with a fresh, sometimes
startled eye. From slow beginnings, the play evolves into a fascinatingly
intricate web. It starts in Bart's casualty unit, where Clive Owen's
Dan, a knight in rather dull armour, has brought Liza Walker's elfin
Alice after seeing her knocked down on Blackfriars Bridge. Dan writes
obituaries, and is a would-be author in search of a subject. Alice
is a young, pretty stripper whose vulnerable appearance belies a steely
emotional absolutism. Dan moves in with Alice, writes a book about
her, then falls for Sally Dexter's voluptuous photographer Anna while
she's taking his publicity pics. Posing on the Internet as a sluttish,
fantasy version of Anna, he unwittingly introduces her to Ciaran Hinds's
Larry, a coarse but kindly doctor who coincidentally examined Alice
in the first scene. Thus begins an intense and often savage quadrille
of romance and betrayal. What distinguishes Marber's script is his
unflinching depiction of the brutality of relationships. Sexual jealousy
rears its head in ugly, graphic detail. Hinds's helplessly nice Larry
resorts to cruelty and self-abasement when rejected. Dan and Anna are
unmasked as cowardly liars. Only Alice remains honest, and she pays
for it. Marber also hints that his characters' romantic betrayals are
a symptom of inevitable compromise. This is pessimistic stuff but Closer
is rarely sombre. The script is studded with dry, understated wit and
moments of rare inspiration. The scene where Dan and Larry talk dirty
on the Internet is a brilliant piece of comic staging. Humour aside,
the play offers audiences four very talented, very attractive actors
sparking off each other. The brittle brightness of Liza Walker contrasts
beautifully with Sally Dexter's resonant sensuality. Clive Owen's offhand
handsomeness is juxtaposed with Ciaran Hinds's graven solemnity. Marber's
direction is spare and sensitive, drawing fine performances from all
four. The various props of Vicki Mortimer's stylish set gradually stack
up at the back of the stage, like bad memories. The brittle brightness
of Liza Walker contrasts beautifully with Sally Dexter's resonant sensuality.
Clive Owen's offhand handsomeness is juxtaposed with Ciaran Hinds's
graven solemnity. Marber's direction is spare and sensitive, drawing
fine performances from all four. The various props of Vicki Mortimer's
stylish set gradually stack up at the back of the stage, like bad memories.
My only major criticism is that Closer lacks the driving conviction
of Dealer's Choice, which focused on blokes and their obsessions. Here,
Marber gains scope but loses some narrative impetus. The dark psychological
secrets confessed by the women sound less convincing than those of
the men. That aside, this is an extraordinarily frank and funny play,
written, directed and acted with real feeling." London Evening
Standard
**********************************************
"When my neighbour asked during the interval of Patrick Marber's
new play whether I was enjoying the evening, I answered: "Sort
of," and if he had repeated his question at the end my reply would
have been just as hesitantly unenthusiastic. The setting is neatly
intriguing, the placing of the scenes in various London locales gives
the illusion of hurried lives busily led; the four performances are
undoubtedly vivid and detailed; but the general effect is oddly unengaging.
For all that Marber's characters involve themselves in the stormiest
passions of love and need, betrayal, remorse, vengeful truth-telling
and lies, the over-arching intention of the play stays out of sight.
Many people find loving desirable but difficult is that it? Or
loving the same person for more than a year or two is gruelling work?
Loving is hating that could be it, perhaps. Or even, bearing
the title in mind, that we are never so far away from someone as when
we live together. None of these possible answers earns top points for
originality, but a dramatist can play many a new tune on old strings,
and Marber comes up with several good snatches. But at the end of the
evening when everything, including death, has come their way, the feeling
persists that nothing has actually happened at all. The rear wall of
Vicki Mortimer's set is hung with memorial plaques and represents Postman's
Park, Aldersgate, a corner of London that many of us will never have
heard of. Here the artist G.F. Watts (painter of Hope, the doleful
woman strumming a broken lyre) erected glazed Doulton tablets to commemorate
people who lost their lives while saving others. When the play releases
this information we guess that the site has not been idly chosen. Maybe
the reference is to Daniel's behaviour, in rescuing a waif who has
let herself be struck by a car on nearby Blackfriars Bridge, and who
sacrifices his happiness (though not his life) thereafter. But it could
equally refer to the elfin waif, Alice, whose enigmatic directness
of response is one of the play's happier achievements. All four characters
are in the body business. The unattractive Daniel writes obituaries
for a newspaper, Anna photographs people while they are still alive,
Larry is a doctor at Bart's specialising in skin complaints, Alice
strips. They meet, love, need, betray and the rest of it over a period
of four years, as though in all London only the four of them were available
for amorous attack. Combat is how Marber presents personal relations
and the quick, cool, tart, crisply phrased, unhesitating repartee expresses
this partial view of the matter ably enough. His choice of what slopes
of their range of feelings to settle upon, almost invariably when only
two characters are present, supplies an interesting variety of venues,
usually when the combatants find themselves in mid-flight between emotions.
And yet, while the players create characters that could almost be real directed
by Marber himself they are given too few of the qualities that
make us want to take note of them. Liza Walker's elusive, father-seeking
Alice gives an eye-catching, intriguing performance, and Ciaran Hinds's
doctor finds the rueful comedy amid the pain. Sally Dexter shows us
guilt, and Clive Owen is the chilled and chilling journo. Many lines,
even some entire scenes, are the real thing. Sort of." The Times
**********************************************
"
Well, he's done it again. Two years ago Patrick Marber made
one of the finest dramatic debuts in recent memory, with Dealer's Choice,
his corrosively funny study of an all-male poker school. Now comes
Closer. Second works are notoriously troublesome but this raw, wounding
drama strikes me as being even better than his first. Though Marber's
style and vision are his own, there are moments in this new piece which
reminded me of both Pinter's Betrayal and David Hare's Skylight. What's
amazing is that Closer can stand comparison with such magnificent plays.
It is, however, necessary to enter a note of warning. Closer is a play
about love, desire, sex, jealousy and guilt. There is no nudity, no
simulated love-making, but the language is as violent and as graphic
as you are likely to encounter outside the pages of a porn magazine.
The obscenity is entirely justified. This is how people, or at least
many people, talk when they are in the grip of the most powerful or
destructive emotions, or when they are engaging in sexual fantasies.
In Marber's script, the f-words and the c-words acquire an intensity
I don't think it's pretentious to describe as poetic. The play, set
in contemporary London, is a sexual quadrille. A journalist (in the
obituaries department, ironically, as it turns out) meets a spunky
young stripper and they fall in love. Then, after a hilarious and riotously
pornographic scene of mistaken identity on the Internet, a male doctor
and a female photographer meet and they too fall in love. And then
love begins to curdle. The journalist and the photographer begin an
affair and hurt their ex-partners grievously. Then the stripper and
the doctor have an affair which has much more to do with mutual despair
and the desire for revenge than it has to do with love. Then . . .
but I won't go on. Not the least of this play's accomplishments is
that you become desperate to know what is going to happen to its anguished,
vulnerable characters next. What I love most about Marber's writing
here is that he gets right down to what Yeats described as "the
foul rag-and-bone shop of the heart". Anyone who has loved and
lost, anyone who has experienced infidelity or felt love die, will
watch this play with stomach churning pangs of recognition. We might
not have spoken as frankly as Marber's characters, but I suspect some
of us will wish that we had. The writing seems to have been ripped
straight from the gut. In contrast, the construction has great formal
beauty, consisting of a series of duologues which gradually move the
action forward, and occasionally back, in time. The sense of artistic
control is formidable, and my only real complaint is that the play's
structure seems a touch too neat for its subject matter. I have no
complaints at all about Marber's bruising, deeply felt production,
or the performances of Liza Walker, Clive Owen, Ciaran Hinds and Sally
Dexter which all ring unerringly true. The scene when Walker desperately
begs her unfaithful boyfriend to stay, the scene when Hinds, like a
man picking at a scab, asks Dexter just what sex was like with her
new lover, have a scorching intensity and emotional truth. I'd be astonished
if there's a better new play this year." The Daily Telegraph
|